The Television & Radio Database

Home  
Members  
Join  
Search  
Listings  

Just A Minute

JAM Series | JAM Stats | JAM Today | JAM Group

Search the JAM Yahoo Group Archive:

 
<<<<   11431   >>>>

Topic: blog posts

Message 1 / 8
Dean BedfordFeb 5, 2019
 
 

A couple of new blog posts may be of interest - this one on Jeremy Hardy http://justaminutesite.blogspot.com/2019/02/jeremy-hardy-rip.html and this one on my lack of updates on the site http://justaminutesite.blogspot.com/2019/02/website-long-absence-and-falling-out-of.html


 
<<<<   11435   >>>>

Topic: Re: blog posts

Message 2 / 8
simonbkellyFeb 6, 2019
 
 
I am always interested to read your posts, Dean, especially as JAM is fast approaching yet another milestone - episode 1000.

Personally, I've always discounted "Silver Minutes" (1992) as being a proper show, even though it included some specially recorded material, as it went out late at night (over 2 weeks) under a different title. Therefore I would also exclude Paul's "Edinburgh Masterclass" (2014), "50 Years of Just a Minute" (2018) and "50 Years in 28 Minutes" (2018). Of course, YMMV...

My episode count to date is 925 Radio 4 episodes plus 28 Carlton TV, 20 BBC1, 10 BBC2 and 12 JJAM making a total of 995 games so episode 1000 will be in 5 weeks time! If you include the above 5 specials then we've already hit 1000. Of course, Nicholas missed 2 shows, but he also recorded two TV pilots that were never broadcast so he will still have participated in 1000 recordings of the show and by the time Series 83 finishes in March he will have appeared in 1000 broadcasts of the game, chairing all but 11 of them. A remarkable achievement...

Your original Geocities site would only have listed 500 of these so that's a hell of a lot of updates you've added to it over the years! With so much info on your site the only way to keep it up to date now would be to use a backend database. If you need help importing the data and creating something more manageable let us know...

Simon
 
<<<<   11436   >>>>

Topic: Re: blog posts

Message 3 / 8
Dean BedfordFeb 6, 2019
 
 
thanks for the kind words!

On 07 February 2019 at 13:57 "simonbkelly@... [just-a-minute]" <just-a-minute@...> wrote:

 

I am always interested to read your posts, Dean, especially as JAM is fast approaching yet another milestone - episode 1000.

Personally, I've always discounted "Silver Minutes" (1992) as being a proper show, even though it included some specially recorded material, as it went out late at night (over 2 weeks) under a different title. Therefore I would also exclude Paul's "Edinburgh Masterclass" (2014), "50 Years of Just a Minute" (2018) and "50 Years in 28 Minutes" (2018). Of course, YMMV...

My episode count to date is 925 Radio 4 episodes plus 28 Carlton TV, 20 BBC1, 10 BBC2 and 12 JJAM making a total of 995 games so episode 1000 will be in 5 weeks time! If you include the above 5 specials then we've already hit 1000. Of course, Nicholas missed 2 shows, but he also recorded two TV pilots that were never broadcast so he will still have participated in 1000 recordings of the show and by the time Series 83 finishes in March he will have appeared in 1000 broadcasts of the game, chairing all but 11 of them. A remarkable achievement...

Your original Geocities site would only have listed 500 of these so that's a hell of a lot of updates you've added to it over the years! With so much info on your site the only way to keep it up to date now would be to use a backend database. If you need help importing the data and creating something more manageable let us know...

Simon


 

 

 
<<<<   11449   >>>>

Topic: Re: blog posts

Message 4 / 8
gstillukMar 16, 2019
 
 
Hey Dean,

What an effort you've put in over the years.  Geocities! :)
I remember Dreamweaver and CoffeCup as early HTML designers. Remember the sadness when I lost my site. :)

To think we're approaching 1,000 episodes. 
I personally love Silver Minutes.  It's one of the things that got me started in the show (what to do with the hole in a doughnut).  Whether it counts as an official show, even with specific material I think you cannot because it would be four shows and most of it is repeats.

I don't think it's the reduction of shine from Clement, I think it's the lack of the camaraderie that the original 4 plus Nicholas had.  In modern times, they've stopped touring (reducing the national interest instantly) and also, Paul is the main regular.  It's become a different show than the four you had.  Even when you had guests you at least had two regulars.  The "feeling" totally changes when you get all the additional guests.  

Yes, there's more choice and more modern choice, but I think that's not the major blame.  It's also more the technology.  We've moved to binging and netflix which means we're more likely to get embroiled in a series on one system, than connect to lots of different systems.  They (and the BBC) need to find a more modern way to release their content.

Now all I've got to do is properly link to my mega app on my phone / tablet and sort out all the episodes I have got.  My old iriver mp3 player (that I've had for close to 20yrs) is still playing and still has the same list of episodes I squeezed on to it, but with a recent phone upgrade I've got the old one now as a replacement media player so I can re-jig things.

Oh and Dean, we're getting older and less energy!  Just accept it! 

 
<<<<   11450   >>>>

Topic: blog posts

Message 5 / 8
Clitheroe KidMar 17, 2019
 
 
Thought I ought in fairness to point out that -

a. In the beginning, *all* the shows were recorded at the BBC's Paris studio
in Lower Regent Street. There was no touring whatsoever during the first 25
years. Yet the show was wildly popular. Its success had nothing to do with
holding recordings outside London, clearly, because no recordings were done
outside London in those days.

b. Kenneth's death is what changed the show.

When Paul replaced him, it more or less went on with 4 new regulars, and was
a very similar show, i.e. one which was still based on the regulars -- until
Derek and Peter both passed away in close proximity, at the turn of the
century.

Yes, it has lost something by having 4 different players every week. There
is no sense of continuity now. Except Nicholas.

It would certainly benefit from emulating 'Clue', i.e. having the same
panellists all the time. But there are no modern players who can do it as
well as the old team. Paul can, but who would you want to have on the show
with him every week? Suggestions on a postcard please!


-----Original Message-----
From: george@... [just-a-minute]
Sent: Saturday, March 16, 2019 10:10 AM
To: just-a-minute@...
Subject: [just-a-minute] Re: blog posts

> I don't think it's the reduction of shine from Clement,
> I think it's the lack of the camaraderie that the original
> 4 plus Nicholas had. In modern times, they've stopped
> touring (reducing the national interest instantly)
> and also, Paul is the main regular. It's become a
> different show than the four you had. Even when you
> had guests you at least had two regulars. The
> "feeling" totally changes when you get all the additional guests.

 
<<<<   11451   >>>>

Topic: Re: blog posts

Message 6 / 8
MarkMar 17, 2019
 
 
It would certainly benefit from emulating 'Clue', i.e. having the same 
panellists all the time.  
 
The peril of having a regular panel is that if you just can't stand one of the regulars, it sours the entire show and may make listeners tune out.
For me, Derek Nimmo always rubbed me up the wrong way with his infantile babblings. And don't get me started on Wendy Richard!
But I like hearing from Julian Clary, who might really annoy other people.

Choosing a new 'gang of four' for the next decade would be difficult indeed.


On Mon, 18 Mar 2019 at 11:31, Clitheroe Kid clitheroekid@... [just-a-minute] <just-a-minute@...> wrote:
 

Thought I ought in fairness to point out that -

a. In the beginning, *all* the shows were recorded at the BBC's Paris studio
in Lower Regent Street. There was no touring whatsoever during the first 25
years. Yet the show was wildly popular. Its success had nothing to do with
holding recordings outside London, clearly, because no recordings were done
outside London in those days.

b. Kenneth's death is what changed the show.

When Paul replaced him, it more or less went on with 4 new regulars, and was
a very similar show, i.e. one which was still based on the regulars -- until
Derek and Peter both passed away in close proximity, at the turn of the
century.

Yes, it has lost something by having 4 different players every week. There
is no sense of continuity now. Except Nicholas.

It would certainly benefit from emulating 'Clue', i.e. having the same
panellists all the time. But there are no modern players who can do it as
well as the old team. Paul can, but who would you want to have on the show
with him every week? Suggestions on a postcard please!


-----Original Message-----
From: george@... [just-a-minute]
Sent: Saturday, March 16, 2019 10:10 AM
To: just-a-minute@...
Subject: [just-a-minute] Re: blog posts

> I don't think it's the reduction of shine from Clement,
> I think it's the lack of the camaraderie that the original
> 4 plus Nicholas had. In modern times, they've stopped
> touring (reducing the national interest instantly)
> and also, Paul is the main regular. It's become a
> different show than the four you had. Even when you
> had guests you at least had two regulars. The
> "feeling" totally changes when you get all the additional guests.



--

 
<<<<   11453   >>>>

Topic: blog posts

Message 7 / 8
Clitheroe KidMar 20, 2019
 
 
This idea came from me, so I feel sort of compelled to reply.

I would quite like to see Gyles Brandreth alongside Paul Merton, as the core
of a new team. Paul is I think universally popular, and Gyles has some of
the virtues of the original foursome, in terms of his intellectual abilitity
to talk on many subjects (he also fulfills Clement's role as a Member of
Parliament). Paul of course fulfills the need to have someone from show
business on the team (the role which Derek Nimmo, Peter Jones and Kenny
Williams had in common).

Julian Clary fulfills somewhat of the 'gay blade' role which Kenny Williams
had. I would not object to him as a permanent fixture. He has the outrageous
element which Kenny provided. But he also has the same unthreatening
personality that Kenny had.

I do not think that I could come up with an obvious fourth choice. But it
ought to be a man. Having a female panellist would unbalance the team,
because she would be in a permanent minority -- the situation which led
Wendy Richard to become defensive and hostile. And which allegedly caused
Nyree Dawn-Porter to break down in tears and flee the studio.

(I have to repeat a previous comment I made: I actually knew Wendy slightly,
I had met her in private life, and she was not at all like she came across
in the show. She was much more relaxed "off", and really very nice. I think
she was not intellectually equipped to play the game like Derek, Clement and
Kenneth did, and she was aware of it, and she over-compensated.)

You would not need to have all 4 regulars in the show every week, but it
would be understood that there was a regular quartet around whom guests
could be featured.


-----Original Message-----
From: Mark sirnylon@... [just-a-minute]
Sent: Monday, March 18, 2019 3:04 AM
To: just-a-minute@...
Subject: Re: [just-a-minute] blog posts

The peril of having a regular panel is that if you just can't stand one of
the regulars, it sours the entire show and may make listeners tune out.
For me, Derek Nimmo always rubbed me up the wrong way with his infantile
babblings. And don't get me started on Wendy Richard!
But I like hearing from Julian Clary, who might really annoy other people.

Choosing a new 'gang of four' for the next decade would be difficult indeed.


On Mon, 18 Mar 2019 at 11:31, Clitheroe Kid clitheroekid@...
[just-a-minute] <just-a-minute@...> wrote:

Thought I ought in fairness to point out that -

a. In the beginning, *all* the shows were recorded at the BBC's Paris studio
in Lower Regent Street. There was no touring whatsoever during the first 25
years. Yet the show was wildly popular. Its success had nothing to do with
holding recordings outside London, clearly, because no recordings were done
outside London in those days.

b. Kenneth's death is what changed the show.

When Paul replaced him, it more or less went on with 4 new regulars, and was
a very similar show, i.e. one which was still based on the regulars -- until
Derek and Peter both passed away in close proximity, at the turn of the
century.

Yes, it has lost something by having 4 different players every week. There
is no sense of continuity now. Except Nicholas.

It would certainly benefit from emulating 'Clue', i.e. having the same
panellists all the time. But there are no modern players who can do it as
well as the old team. Paul can, but who would you want to have on the show
with him every week? Suggestions on a postcard please!


-----Original Message-----
From: george@... [just-a-minute]
Sent: Saturday, March 16, 2019 10:10 AM
To: just-a-minute@...
Subject: [just-a-minute] Re: blog posts

> I don't think it's the reduction of shine from Clement,
> I think it's the lack of the camaraderie that the original
> 4 plus Nicholas had. In modern times, they've stopped
> touring (reducing the national interest instantly)
> and also, Paul is the main regular. It's become a
> different show than the four you had. Even when you
> had guests you at least had two regulars. The
> "feeling" totally changes when you get all the additional guests.

 
<<<<   11455   >>>>

Topic: Re: blog posts

Message 8 / 8
MarkMar 20, 2019
 
 
'I do not think that I could come up with an obvious fourth choice. But it 
ought to be a man. Having a female panellist would unbalance the team, 
because she would be in a permanent minority'

That's an interesting way to start a fight!  ðŸ˜€
Demelza - care to step in?

I can see many women capable of restraining their exploding uteruses long enough to be formidable competitors.
Let's start with S01E02 and Sheila Hancock who can still give the men a hearty verbal spanking 52 years later.

💅

On Thu, 21 Mar 2019 at 11:07, Clitheroe Kid clitheroekid@... [just-a-minute] <just-a-minute@...> wrote:
 

This idea came from me, so I feel sort of compelled to reply.

I would quite like to see Gyles Brandreth alongside Paul Merton, as the core
of a new team. Paul is I think universally popular, and Gyles has some of
the virtues of the original foursome, in terms of his intellectual abilitity
to talk on many subjects (he also fulfills Clement's role as a Member of
Parliament). Paul of course fulfills the need to have someone from show
business on the team (the role which Derek Nimmo, Peter Jones and Kenny
Williams had in common).

Julian Clary fulfills somewhat of the 'gay blade' role which Kenny Williams
had. I would not object to him as a permanent fixture. He has the outrageous
element which Kenny provided. But he also has the same unthreatening
personality that Kenny had.

I do not think that I could come up with an obvious fourth choice. But it
ought to be a man. Having a female panellist would unbalance the team,
because she would be in a permanent minority -- the situation which led
Wendy Richard to become defensive and hostile. And which allegedly caused
Nyree Dawn-Porter to break down in tears and flee the studio.

(I have to repeat a previous comment I made: I actually knew Wendy slightly,
I had met her in private life, and she was not at all like she came across
in the show. She was much more relaxed "off", and really very nice. I think
she was not intellectually equipped to play the game like Derek, Clement and
Kenneth did, and she was aware of it, and she over-compensated.)

You would not need to have all 4 regulars in the show every week, but it
would be understood that there was a regular quartet around whom guests
could be featured.


-----Original Message-----
From: Mark sirnylon@... [just-a-minute]
Sent: Monday, March 18, 2019 3:04 AM
To: just-a-minute@...
Subject: Re: [just-a-minute] blog posts

The peril of having a regular panel is that if you just can't stand one of
the regulars, it sours the entire show and may make listeners tune out.
For me, Derek Nimmo always rubbed me up the wrong way with his infantile
babblings. And don't get me started on Wendy Richard!
But I like hearing from Julian Clary, who might really annoy other people.

Choosing a new 'gang of four' for the next decade would be difficult indeed.


On Mon, 18 Mar 2019 at 11:31, Clitheroe Kid clitheroekid@...
[just-a-minute] <just-a-minute@...> wrote:

Thought I ought in fairness to point out that -

a. In the beginning, *all* the shows were recorded at the BBC's Paris studio
in Lower Regent Street. There was no touring whatsoever during the first 25
years. Yet the show was wildly popular. Its success had nothing to do with
holding recordings outside London, clearly, because no recordings were done
outside London in those days.

b. Kenneth's death is what changed the show.

When Paul replaced him, it more or less went on with 4 new regulars, and was
a very similar show, i.e. one which was still based on the regulars -- until
Derek and Peter both passed away in close proximity, at the turn of the
century.

Yes, it has lost something by having 4 different players every week. There
is no sense of continuity now. Except Nicholas.

It would certainly benefit from emulating 'Clue', i.e. having the same
panellists all the time. But there are no modern players who can do it as
well as the old team. Paul can, but who would you want to have on the show
with him every week? Suggestions on a postcard please!


-----Original Message-----
From: george@... [just-a-minute]
Sent: Saturday, March 16, 2019 10:10 AM
To: just-a-minute@...
Subject: [just-a-minute] Re: blog posts

> I don't think it's the reduction of shine from Clement,
> I think it's the lack of the camaraderie that the original
> 4 plus Nicholas had. In modern times, they've stopped
> touring (reducing the national interest instantly)
> and also, Paul is the main regular. It's become a
> different show than the four you had. Even when you
> had guests you at least had two regulars. The
> "feeling" totally changes when you get all the additional guests.




--
The Upload Jar - so you can send me stuff to put into any Jar.
Beyond our Ken - http://bit.ly/2C3mpqH
Round the Horne - http://bit.ly/2OIlRxm

 
<<<<   11455   >>>>

Back to the Top
 

Message History

 JanFebMarAprMayJunJulAugSepOctNovDec
201910231211351191231414
201847218937951925514
20174342212172041923442316
201613493957608710322412923
201551973249415420280143116
201497568332833528251323879
2013463251988781192889886385427
2012921211801991258871155118166125144
20111127871731342252521526218316563
20101421171539469496918382716875
200967454297901491107063423539
2008200120175120701098711571455838
2007165447132999557140118748812599

|   FAQ   |   Contact   |   Services   |   Terms   |   Privacy   |   Credits   |

[Page generated in 0.0774 seconds under 1.43% server load]

© 2012-2025 TVRDb.com. All rights reserved.