Just A Minute

JAM Series | JAM Stats | JAM Today | JAM Group

<<<< 1680 >>>>

Re: Clement Freud on his grandfather

Messages in this topic: 12 View All
Robert TorresJan 8, 2008

Good point. :)

it kinda follows from that same logic if you say, 'if there are two apples, and you take two away, how many would you have, and you'd say zero', which technically is incorrect. because you are the one taking them away, so you'd have the two apples.

Alexis Birkill <yahoo@...> wrote:

--- In just-a-minute@ yahoogroups. com, Robert Torres
<bobbyshaddoe3004@ ...> wrote:
>
> For instance, when the subject was 'Clement Freud' many years ago,
Derek mentioned that Clement had a grandfather, and Clement challenged
in saying that he had two grandfathers, not one. and Nicholas
disallowed the challenge because of some erroneous claim that if
Clement has two grandfathers then he must have one, which doesn't make
sense. if you have two grandfathers, you have two grandfathers, one
from each side of the family.

I disagree! If I have two apples I also have one apple - to prove this
I can eat one apple and still have one remaining.

Similarly, if you have a pile of 100 bricks, and I ask you if I can
have one brick, a reply stating that you don't have one brick would be
erroneous.

:)

A.

Be a better friend, newshound, and know-it-all with Yahoo! Mobile. Try it now.

<<<< 1680 >>>>

Back to the Top

Message History

	Jan	Feb	Mar	Apr	May	Jun	Jul	Aug	Sep	Oct	Nov	Dec
2019	10	23	12	1	13	5	1	19	12	31	4	14
2018	4	7	21	8	9	37	9	5	19	25	5	14
2017	4	34	22	12	17	20	4	19	23	44	23	16
2016	13	49	39	57	60	87	10	32	24	12	9	23
2015	51	97	32	49	41	54	20	28	0	14	31	16
2014	9	75	68	33	28	33	52	82	51	32	38	79
2013	463	251	98	87	81	192	88	98	86	38	54	27
2012	92	121	180	199	125	88	71	155	118	166	125	144
2011	112	78	71	73	134	225	252	152	62	183	165	63
2010	142	117	153	94	69	49	69	183	82	71	68	75
2009	67	45	42	97	90	149	110	70	63	42	35	39
2008	200	120	175	120	70	109	87	115	71	45	58	38
2007	165	447	132	99	95	57	140	118	74	88	125	99