Just A Minute

 
<<<<   521   >>>>

Re: New vs Old

Messages in this topic: 33 View All
DaveFeb 22, 2007
 

 
--- In just-a-minute@..., "bobbyshaddoe3004"
<bobbyshaddoe3004@...> wrote:

This was, in part, my point exactly.

> The fact is, Nicholas has often stated time immemorial, that evenif
> you don't know a thing about a subject, you still have to talk

about

> it irrespective. The reason some of these individuals decided to
> read up on this sort of information, because they usually CHOOSE to
> do so for their own reasons, usually to work their comedy about the
> place they happen to be visiting.
>
> I myself have been accused of being pedantic on things regarding

this

> show, but I think this is just getting a bit TOO pedantic. The
> subject Sue was talking about was 'Old Father Thames' and when she
> had the subject she did very well with it, discussing him as well

as

> Old Mother Thames. I think the issue over Sue's alleged ignorance
> regarding the Serpentine and the Thames is totally immaterial.

I'm quite happy to be accused of 'pedantry on an industrial scale' to
quote Stephen Fry, but if you check this wasn't the only instance
with this particular player. To continue the Fry quotes 'I'll hold up
my end for the Radio 4 listener'.

>
> --- In just-a-minute@..., "Dave" <j_a_m_fan@> wrote:
> >
> > I've never lived in London either; or Portsmouth. HMS Victory was
> > Nelson's flag ship at the battle of Trafalgar and a huge point of
> > civic pride that it is preserved there, I'm sure.
> >
> > My point is that Graham Norton has never lived in Sheffield, but

on

> > his appearances there he had done what research he could; Sheila
> > Hancock in the Hastings recording had done the same, even stating
> she
> > had anticipated local questions. These performers know the game
> > format when its out on the road (ie. not in London), and approach
> it
> > with a suitable degree of professionalism.
> >
> >
> > --- In just-a-minute@..., "Nathan Leonard"
> > <dreadedwoekitten@> wrote:
> > >
> > > I have to say that although I have heard of the HMS Victory, I
> > couldn't tell
> > > you offhand why it's famous. And I thought the Serpentine was

a

> > river, not
> > > a lake. Mind you, I've never lived in London.
> > >
> > > On 2/20/07, dbedford@ <dbedford@> wrote:
> > > >
> > > > > I expect this will probably not make me popular around
> > > > > here, but I have to say that I firmly believe that Just a
> > > > > Minute has actually been much better in recent years than
> > > > > it was in times of old.
> > > >
> > > > I wouldn't think you would be in the minority actually. On
> > > > the TV show Arena a few years ago, Nick himself reckoned it
> > > > was funnier these days. Of course these days most of the
> > > > cast are professional comedians, which Kenneth, Clement,
> > > > Peter, Derek and most of their contemporaries were not.
> > > >
> > > > I personally like both "versions" if that's the right word
> > > > in different ways. I do feel the current show shuffles the
> > > > pack too much and you miss out on the really great banter
> > > > and interaction that comes when everyone knows exactly how
> > > > to pull everyone else's string. And I like the drama that
> > > > Kenneth offered. But Paul and Graham do come out with
> > > > funnier lines and stories. My Desert Island list included
> > > > plenty from both eras. :)
> > > >
> > > >
> > >
> >
>

 
<<<<   521   >>>>

Back to the Top