Just A Minute

 
<<<<   6161   >>>>

Re: Nic's errors league table

Messages in this topic: 6 View All
kj.naughtonOct 27, 2011
 

 
Hi all,

...and to be equally clear, I'm not offended by anyone's recent posts so please let no-one take what I say as a criticism of them or as an attempt to stop people discussing what they like. I certainly don't want the group to be one that only talks about "good things".

If Espen read my post as comparing his with the earlier ones, then that's not what I intended and I'm sorry it came across that way. My intention was simply to disagree with Dave B and point out that not all posts with lots of replies counted as "successful". I gave the example of the mental health posts as examples of that and in no way intended to draw a link between those unfortunate posts and Espen's valid points.

So please let's not just go into "unconditional praise" and I'm all in favour of criticism. But I have boundaries of my own personal taste and I will say when I think people have crossed them - I don't expect others to agree and I don't claim to be a referee for anyone else. But no-one recently has come even close to crossing into my definition of poor taste, let alone of offending me.

But I still think that Clitheroe Kid did have some valid point. It is fair and reasonable (IMHO) to criticise Nic's performances and consistency providing that it's well informed and doesn't cross into personal attacks. And Clitheroe Kid helps to inform that criticism by pointing out that what you hear on the radio isn't what happened on stage.

Cheers

kJ

--- In just-a-minute@..., Espen Krømke <espen.kromke@...> wrote:
>
> On 27. okt. 2011 11:24, kj.naughton wrote:
>
> I remember this too, those posts were utterly annoying and let me right
> away make one thing clear: I do *not* mean to bash Nick at all. And if
> that is how my mails are perceived then please all, accept my apologies.
> But to even put my posts in the same category as someone questioning his
> mental faculties is... Well... Pretty darn extreme.

 
<<<<   6161   >>>>

Back to the Top