Home  

Members  

Join  

Search  

Listings  

 
<<<<   6497   >>>>

Topic: Wrong Challenge

Message 1 / 2
kryptoshahJan 18, 2012
 

 
ahem,

 
<<<<   6501   >>>>

Topic: Re: Wrong Challenge

Message 2 / 2
kj.naughtonJan 19, 2012
 

 
Hi folks

I don't mean to be pedantic (actually I do mean to be pedantic but it's polite to say that). Clement was wrong to say he'd repeated "address" but Nicholas was correct to give against him. By the time Clement buzzed he had repeated "address".

In fact in most of these "self challenges" this sort of self-fulfilling prophesy is likely to happen and so Nicholas will usually be right in allowing the challenge.

Cheers

kJ

--- In just-a-minute@..., kryptoshah@... wrote:
>
> ahem,
>
> i would like to put on record an instance when a panelist wrongly
> challenged himself for repetition. Nicholas Parsons got it wrong too.
>
> from the transcript of (Radio, 17 September 1973).
>
> THEME MUSIC
>
> ANNOUNCER: We present Clement Freud, Peter Jones, Warren Mitchell and Jean
> Marsh in Just A Minute. And as the Minute Waltz fades away here to tell you
> about it is our chairman Nicholas Parsons.
>
> NICHOLAS PARSONS: Thank you, thank you very much indeed, hello and welcome
> to Just A Minute. And we're delighted to welcome back Warren Mitchell and
> Jean Marsh to play the game with Peter Jones and Clement Freud, who have
> played it so often before. Once again they're going to try and speak if
> they can on some unlikely subject without hesitation, without repetition
> and without deviating from the subject on the card. And we begin the show
> this week with Clement Freud. And Clement, the subject that Ian Messiter
> has thought of is cobber. Would you talk on cobber for 60 seconds starting
> now.
>
> CLEMENT FREUD: Cobber is the sort of thing that nice people are called in
> Australia. You don't say "good morning sir", "good afternoon gentleman". Or
> anything of that kind. Cobber suffices. Taxi drivers are hailed by that
> name. Bus conductors stop when you address them as... I am sorry, I said
> address before. I think somebody ought to buzz. I'll buzz myself.
>
> BUZZ
>
> NP: Clement Freud, you've challenged yourself.
>
> CF: I repeat, I repeated myself and being a totally honest man...
>
> NP: Well you were listening extremely well, much better than everybody
> else! You get a point for a correct challenge and you keep... And there are
> 33 seconds left on cobber with you starting now.
>
> ....
>
> just sharing :-)
>
>
>
>
> --
> cheers
> dr kamal shah
>